Friday, December 14, 2007

People's Opinions

After reading my blog post on people's thoughts being influenced by various means - news articles, family, friends, books, editorials - rather than by what candidates say, a friend asked me what was a good example of something that could influence people. That reminded me of a recent documentary I had seen.

I had picked up the "Voices of Iraq" from the local library, happening to see it when I walked by. "Filmed and Directed by the People of Iraq" the cover said, interesting me at once. My long years with Asha and similar organizations had exposed me to the critical importance of listening to what people had to say. Nothing can come close to what the people have to say about themselves, their lives, their travails, their goals. In the Asha's context it is the people whose children we are trying "educate", but it applies everywhere. This is the basis premise of projects like "Kids with Cameras" (www.kids-with-cameras.org) which gave cameras to children in a red-light district giving the opportunity of expressing themselves, and is also the reason why digital story-telling is rapidly catching on.

So I picked up the DVD immediately, thinking this would be a great documentary to see. Learning about the situation in Iraq from the Iraqis themselves - nothing could be closer to the truth. The producers had distributed 150 video cameras in the entire country of Iraq, to "enable everyday people - mothers, children, teachers, sheikhs, even insurgents - to document their lives and their hopes amidst the upheavel of a nation being born". I was going visit my parents that weekend, and they would enjoy it too.

We sat down to watch the video, and it started by presenting the perspective of people living in the marshes who had been persecuted under Saddam's regime, then described how the poor did not have access to education under Saddam and about how some had been very poor, it showed various injustices some had had to undergo under that regime - all described by the people themselves. It was moving. Saddam indeed had been a tyrant ......all these people had suffered so. And there was hope that came through in the film - that with Saddam out of the way, there was real hope of a truly democratic nation being born, of a better life for them and their children. The thought crossed my mind - had I realized how brutal Saddam was till I heard the Iraqi people themselves speak? I guess not. There was excellent footage about the Iraqi countryside, Iraqis celebrating their festivals, having fun, living their way of life.

Halfway into the documentary several Iraqis applauded the US government for ridding them of Saddam. I began to think that there might be some who think that way, but did they all? Weren't there some who did not like the US government's actions? Maybe not, if all 150 film makers across the country liked what the US government had done. This was a new view for me - I had not realized that so many Iraqis felt this way. Then Abu Ghraib came up. "People who were tortured and humilitated deserved it, since they were the jailors in the prisons under Saddam's rule", said one. That didn't somehow ring true. Really? I had not heard that before (keeping aside the question of whether that made torture OK). It then began to dawn on me ...... that the voices of the Iraqi people were the voices of _some_ Iraqi people. Was it really a representative sample? Didn't seem like it. Who were the cameras given to? How were they selected? Were other differing opinions edited out? As the documentary progressed, it became more and more obvious that this was convervative propaganda - that it was a documentary put together to put forth one point of view, the view that the US did the right thing in invading Iraq and "freeing" the people from the dictator Saddam. But the way it was done was diabolically clever. I would never, never, never have doubted anything that proclaimed itself as being the 'voices of Iraq'. I would have never have attributed anything but the finest of motives to something that gave video cameras to people so that they can tell their story their own way. I was stunned that even I, who was opposed to every reason the US gave for invading Iraq, could get fooled for a whole hour. It was so convincing, so well done, seemed so representative of what the man on the street felt that it was hard to believe it was propaganda, except for some obvious falsehoods in the second half of the documentary.

I was mad. I wanted to write a strong note to the public library for carrying such a documentary without saying it was propaganda. I was annoyed that propagondists would use methods which are honored by grassroots activists as means of giving people a voice.

Here is how public opinion can be influenced.

Ron Paul

Hmmm....... Ron Paul's supporters are *really* on the move. I hear that liberatarians from all over the country have descended on New Hampshire, sensing a real opportunity for Ron Paul to cause an upset in New Hampshire. I guess these supporters are all working hard - I am getting at least one call a day, often two, with a recorded message from the Ron Paul campaign (when I was home with a cold it began to get a bit annoying). I like Ron Paul a lot, and think he says exactly what he believes in, but one message put me off - his stance on illegal immigration which included saying that children of illegal immigrants should not be citizens and a few other things (reminded me of a cartoon in my local town newspaper a while back - a native American was sending European settlers away saying they are illegal immigrants :)).

There have been tons of mailings as well - literally one every alternate day. Not to mention flyers stuck in my door, and canvassing volunteers I run into while canvassing for Edwards. Clearly his supporters are going all out. Will be interesting to see what happens in the Republican primary!

Straight Talk Express

John McCain had my deepest respect as someone who had been a POW for 5 years. I had seen him in 2000, and had been impressed with what came across as a very honest demeanor – straight talk it was. I hoped he would win the nomination rather than Bush, but politics does not always work that way.

This time around, I of course completely opposed his stance on the war. I still liked several of the values he stood for, for campaign finance reform which he attempted, for his commitment to not have torture, for his humane look at illegal immigrants. But I simply did not understand his stance on the war. When I heard his son was in the marines, I began to realize that he really, really believed in the war – having his son fighting and supporting the war made him better in my eyes than someone supporting the war from one’s cushy home, though it did alter my position against his candidacy.

He was speaking at the senior citizens center in Nashua, and I took care to park several blocks away (the anti-war stickers make my car stand out in Republican candidate events J). The atmosphere in the room had a lot of energy (a bit like an Edwards’ event actually), with people from a cross-section of society, many with a strong belief in the candidate. The woman sitting next to me was undecided, though strongly leaning towards him, and had voted for him 2000. I was lucky to get a seat in the third row, a great place to be in to ask a question. The New Hamsphire Peace Action had left a message for me to try and bird-dogging questions, and I was intending to try (though I was a bit nervous ;)).

He came in, and it struck me that he was old (I believe he is 71). He was feisty and started by saluting all the veterans in the room, who clearly adore him. A POW, who had been tortured, who spent 5 years in prison not knowing whether he would ever get back home, right there in front of me. It felt good to applaud him.

His talk came across as straight talk. Then it was time for questions. One man, who had lived in Arizona before, asked, “Senator, I like you very much, and I would really, really like to vote for you. But I need to hear some strong statements on illegal immigration. I think it is a serious problem, and all security at our front door would be useless if we left our back door open. You will have to convince me on your stand on that issue if you want my vote”. Oh my. New Hampshire town hall meetings can be tough! McCain answered outlining his stance, that a wall would work in some places, but we would never several other things, like sensors, cameras, a beefed up border patrol etc etc., and faulted the federal government for not having done much to stem it. But it was not a strong statement bashing illegal immigrants as law-breakers, and I doubt the man decided to vote for him.

Another person said that she had read that he was in favor of social security for illegal immigrants. He answered, “No”, which is all the questioner wanted to hear. He went to say that we should think of them in a humane manner, as God’s children, but he did not think we should give them amnesty. I did a double take on that – I thought there was a whole section during an early Republican debate where he talked about the definition of amnesty, and said that giving amnesty was not the same as rewarding them, which the other candidates were accusing him of. Had he changed his stance?

I pondered for a few moments on why illegal immigration is such a scary issue. It is not as though New Hampshire is burdened by a lot of people coming in and making use of public services. Why did it bother people so much? What was the fear? A fear that a way of life would be changed? After all, tons of immigrants had come in to the US, and tons from all cultures were coming in “legally”. Or was it a fear that an “open” border was not good for security? And there are not really a whole lot of illegal immigrants doing landscaping and snow-plowing and car-washing in New Hampshire. All these jobs are still done by New Hampshire folks. The whole immigration issue did not strike me as a critical question that needed to be addressed immediately from New Hampshire’s point of view, but fear is a great political tool. If people felt fear they will lean towards someone who they think will help make that fear go away. Thus it has become a campaign issue!

Several questions revolved around the Iraq war and the larger “idealogical war”, and how military intervention was necessary to put an end to this threat to the US. He clearly blurred the lines between Al Qaeda and Iraq, talking about the brutal dictator Iraq had been under and saying in the same breath that we have to win the war in Iraq to make sure that Al Qaeda was defeated. At one point he talked about the cold war, and about how it was won not by force but by “being a superior civilization”. Then I thought I should ask the question – why did he think this “idealogical war” should be won by force? And a good addition to the question would be – if it is Al Qaeda we are after, why did we go into Iraq? He also talked about nuclear energy being very useful as an alternate means of energy. Why were we objecting to Iran having a nuclear program then?

I raised by hand, but by then it was apparent that there were 3 other peace activists in the room, raising their hands with bird-dogging questions (two I recognized as being with the Nashua Peace Group and Americans Against Escalation of the War in Iraq). They were veterans in asking questions, and I did not want to interfere with their chances of being called on, especially because they were both sitting close to me. So they asked their questions and I did not get to ask mine.

At the end of all this, what stood out was that for all the straight talk there were inconsistencies when he talked. Did he honestly and truly believe that this was an ideological war? Did he honestly believe it was alright to have the “collateral damage” of Iraqi civilians when he talked about basic, inalienable human rights of every human being? In answer to a question he had talked so much about the basic, inalienable rights of every human being in the world - how does the reconcile the Right to Live and the “collateral damage” in Iraq? Did he honestly and truly believe thee was a connection between Iraq and Al Qaeda? And how come he changed his position on amnesty? Finally even McCain seemed to be giving in to positions which would help win the election. It was a bit disappointing, and my initial mild euphoria in seeing him rapidly vanished. I could not feel that McCain truly believed in the connections he was making regarding the war….. so was he just saying that to win the election?

Monday, December 3, 2007

Door-to-door again

My car showed a temperature of 24 F. And it was windy. Bitterly cold. Not an ideal day for campaigning at all, but the Edwards campaign is relentless - rain or shine or snow or cold, folks are out there.

This time there were more people for Hillary than last time, though there were still many undecideds. Sigh. Lot of work to do before we can get Edwards elected.

We did half the streets we had to do on that day, and on one street we were right behind a Ron Paul campaigner. On another street we saw Obama's campaign a couple of houses ahead of us, at which point we decided to give up and go home and come back the next day - we didn't think voters would take kindly to 3 campaigns visiting them in the space of 15 minutes. This is going to be the trend till January 8th I think, as all the campaigns become more and more aggressive.

The Edwards campaign (and all other campaigns I am sure), have grassroots campaigning down to an art. Every voter has to be visited at least twice. If they are not home, we leave a booklet by the door, and the campaign follows up in a couple of days with a call asking whether the voter has any questions on the booklet. Jack, the staff member in charge of wards 1 and 3, knows practically every Edwards voter in his wards. Edwards voters are called to see whether they would be volunteers. All the data we collect on who will vote for whom is meticulously stored in the database, and will be used on election day - when we make sure that everyone who has said they will vote for Edwards makes it to the polls. Every vote counts!

Monday, November 26, 2007

January 8th it is!

So we again preserve the first-in-the-nation-primary status of the New Hampshire primaries. This drama has been going on for two years now. The Democratic party at the national level has been trying to have a more "balanced" early primary season, which more accurately reflects the demographics of the US. The logical part of me of course agrees with that. But the New Hampshire resident part of me does not - it is way too much to live in a state with the first-in-the-nation-primary! No way we are giving that up :) The local newspapers have closely followed the attempt to reduce the importance of New Hampshire, with many editorials devoted to how the New Hampshire's town hall style campaigning is critical to the political process, and how New Hampshire voters are so well-informed. All true, I think :)

The process of setting the date rests in the hands of the New Hampshire Secretary of State, Bill Gardner. New Hampshire has a law that states that we have to go before everyone else - interesting law, because it can get difficult to implement it by ourselves :) A few months ago, everyone started leap-frogging, much to our alarm. The Democratic party chose to have the Nevada caucuses on January 19th (the then tentative New Hampshire primary date was January 22nd or so), though after some thought that seemed OK. It was just a caucus after all. But then Florida moved ahead, Michigan declared a move to January 15th, and all major states (California, New York, etc.) moved their primary to February 5, after which the primaries would virtually be over. If we were too close to the day when practically every other state voted, we would lose our influence. But where could we move to? Every Tuesday seemed to be taken up. There was talking of holding the New Hampshire primary in December, and national newspapers lamented that voters might be going to the polls along with Christmas carolers. As a local newspaper cartoon put it beautifully - in a picture of leap-frogging frogs, the Iowa frog tells the New Hampshire frog - "I don't know about you, but we are holding our elections today!".

Iowa finally set its caucuses to be on January 3rd, and New Hampshire chose January 8th. It is a bit too close to Iowa's caucuses - a full week would be nice - but at least we are preserving the order which New Hampshire residents think is their birthright :) Iowa holds caucuses, while New Hampshire holds a primary, which more accurately reflects the general election. Also in New Hampshire voters registered as independents can vote in the primary, so a result in New Hampshire can reflect the mood of voters who are independents. Iowa's caucuses are always held first, followed by the first-in-the-nation-primary in New Hampshire.

The elections are beginning too close to the holidays, and are way too compressed. But as a New York Times columnist put it, yet again we have managed to keep the critical phase of electing a new president in the preserve of some very, very special people who live in very, very special places :)

Monday, November 19, 2007

Calling

Calling voters to campaign for Edwards was simpler than I expected. I had to tell people that Edwards was going in town the following week, give them the time and location, and ask them whether they had decided on a candidate. Having a specific message like that was better than just campaigning on the phone.

I rapidly realized that people really are making up their own mind. There really is nothing much one can say to convince them - they decide based on their interests and their observations, and primary voters are generally well-informed. For example, Edwards wants to raise the minimum wage. If a voter does not agree with that, there is nothing much you can do while campaigning. All you can do is explain Edwards' position, but not change their opinion on what they feel about minimum wage. Change in thought has to come at a more fundamental level - through discussions, reading articles and books, and very importantly through thoughts of family and friends around one. So a campaign essentially becomes an operation that is trying to figure out what people want and planning one's positions accordingly, instead deciding on a position and convincing people that that is the right position (for example, that the minimum wage has to be increased, or that America's foreign policy has to be changed). So campaigns "pander" to the voters.

Hmmm. I guess that is what democracy is supposed to be - leaders' positions reflect what people want. However leaders try to influence the voters in other ways ..... like managing to get people to think that the war against Iraq was necessary, all through subtly influencing people's thoughts, playing on their insecurities, presenting dreams as possibilities.

Anyway, coming back to Edwards. One gentleman felt he was liberal, and wanted his positions in writing before he made up his mind. We gladly sent him a policy booklet (a thick booklet which contains his detailed positions in writing - another reason I like Edwards). Next to me at the phones a campaign staff member was having a funny conversation with a voter over the phone. The voter said he did not like Edwards because he was a millionaire. "But so is Hillary" said the campaign staff member. And then went on to add that Edwards is working against the interests of powerful millionaires, unlike other millionaires who are working in cahoots with powerful millionaires. I don't think the voter changed his mind :)

Friday, November 2, 2007

Door-to-Door

I finally gave in and agreed to do some door-to-door campaigning for the Edwards campaign. Volunteers do this in pairs, and since I was new a staff member was going to do it with me. I met up with Paul at the campaign office on a Saturday afternoon and we got started in Ward 1, the ward where I live.

The first few houses were all leaning towards Edwards, which was very encouraging. It was raining the whole day and I think we made a good impression on some people, that we were out campaigning for Edwards even on a cold, rainy day. People were mostly friendly, and I soon figured out the simple tricks of how many times one should knock, figuring out whether one should be knocking on the side door instead of the front door, and so on, essentially tricks to ensure that I would not annoy the person whose door I was knocking on. These were all democrats, and independents who had voted in 2004 (which meant they were probably democratic leaning independents), and this meant that they received Edwards campaign folks in a friendly manner. Paul was good company, and the task was not as bad as I had thought it would be at all.

50-60% were either not at home or did not answer the door (we left literature for them). In the remaining 40-50% three quarters of them had not decided. In the remaining small number of people, a good number had decided on Edwards or were leaning towards him. One said she had decided on Hillary, and one said she did not like Edwards, and that was it. Everyone was either undecided or liked Edwards so far. I decided I was not going to listen to a single poll from now on! Poll results did not seem to reflect what I observed at all (granted this was only in one ward).

Towards the end of the afternoon we decided to go to Alicia Lane, as I had a friend on that street, someone who had been very active in the Dean campaign in 2004. I told Paul we should stop there. That whole street ended up being very good. In the first house on that street the husband said he was undecided but his wife was leaning towards Edwards; to him electability was the most critical thing. Paul was ready with various polls showing Edwards doing well against most Republican front runners. At my friend’s house we went in. Fanny had been very interested in Obama, but lately had said he did not fire her up as Edwards did. We sat down in their living room and I explained why I supported Edwards, and she slowly got convinced – she said, “I really have to get over my infatuation with Obama”, and went on to add that, “I cannot believe that I am not going to vote for a black candidate”. After we left Paul said, “I feel exactly the same way. I want to show that we can elect a black president”. Then he looked at me and said, “I don’t suppose you understand that”, and I said, “no, I don’t”. Fanny and Paul, being progressive whites, felt strongly that they should support a viable black candidate. That was a surprise to me. Having been part of a “minority” pretty much all my life, as Paul said I did not understand (or rather had not thought of that) the desire by the “majority” who are progressive to vote for a “minority” candidate. Interesting.